I can be a real recipe geek, as this pound cake experience clearly illustrates. It all started with wanting to make a lighter homemade poundcake from scratch. A typical slice of pound cake can have upwards of 400 to 500 calories, not something I can afford to indulge in very often. Yet, it’s something I like, probably because it’s so simple and versatile. Great plain, pound cake also is delicious with fruit compote, fruit salad, yogurt, and ice cream.
Suddenly it dawned on me that I’d never even made a regular pound cake from scratch, let alone a lighter one. How could I go about attempting to lighten a pound cake recipe without having made a standard one? (Yes, this is how my geeky recipe brain operates. Or was this just an excuse to dig out lots of butter and sugar? I’m really not sure.)
I decided my Mom’s birthday was the perfect
excuse reason to make her a full fat pound cake that I could then experiment with making lighter later. My pound cake mission had begun.
I searched through lots and lots of cookbooks to decide on a recipe, and learned in the process, that most pound cakes use the same basic ingredients – butter, sugar, eggs, flour, and sometimes milk – but the recipes can vary considerably in the amount of sugar and number of eggs used. Other popular pound cake ingredients include cream cheese and sour cream.
Since I couldn’t seem to choose just one, I decided to make 2 recipes: The Barefoot Contessa’s Honey Vanilla Pound Cake, which appears in her Barefoot Contessa Back to Basics: Fabulous Flavor from Simple Ingredients and the Easy Pound Cake from How to Bake : Complete Guide to Perfect Cakes, Cookies, Pies, Tarts, Breads, Pizzas, Muffins, by Nick Malgieri.
I discounted the pound cake recipe that appears in How to Cook Everything, Completely Revised 10th Anniversary Edition: 2,000 Simple Recipes for Great Food because it’s technique was more involved, requiring that you separate the eggs, whip the whites and then fold them back into the batter. (Even though this is the technique Smitten Kitten swears by and attributes to James beard here in her post for lighter airy pound cake, it seemed like too much work. I wanted “easy.” I definitely need to work on my aversion to whipping and folding egg whites.)
While I didn’t select the Bittman pound cake recipe, he did provide a great suggestion for lightening it: substitute 3/4 cup plain yogurt for 1/2 cup of butter.
By the time I was done investigating and ready to get baking, it was quite late. I pulled out the butter, sugar, flour, eggs, milk, honey, and vanilla and plugged in the KitchenAid . (Rod and Mac quietly exited upstairs to the man cave before the flour began to fly.)
Each of the batters looked, smelled, and tasted delicious.
What I did next, turned out to be a big baking
mistake learning opportunity. I used foil pans and filled them too full. After 30 minutes of baking I looked in the oven to discover batter bubbling and oozing from the pans onto the baking sheet beneath them. I wanted to cry or scream. And the old perfectionist me would have pulled them from the oven, dumped them into the trash, and started over again.
I took a big breath, sighed, closed the oven and decided to let them bake and see how they turned out, knowing they would be far from perfect.
And having just cleaned up the kitchen, I dug out the ingredients, revved up the KitchenAid and mixed together another one to bake in a sturdier pan. This was my Mom’s birthday after all.
Note to self: Get yourself some sturdier regular sized loaf pans and DO NOT overfill them!
While the cakes that had overrun were not picture perfect, they tasted pretty darned good. In our side-by-side tasting, Mom and I both preferred the texture of the Easy Pound Cake (which called for 1/4 cup milk) a little better.
A few days later, I finally baked my lighter pound cake, which I liked best of all, since it was easy, delicious and a little lighter and healthier!
- ½ cup (1 stick) butter, softened
- 1 cup sugar
- 4 large eggs, at room temperature
- ¾ cup plain yogurt
- ¼ teaspoon salt
- Pinch of ground mace* (optional)
- 1-1/2 teaspoons vanilla
- ¼ cup milk
- ¾ teaspoon baking powder
- 2 cups cake flour
- Grease an 8 x 4-inch loaf pan. Line the bottom of the pan with parchment or wax paper, so the pound cake doesn’t stick to the bottom when you try to remove it.
- Position an oven rack in the middle level of the oven and preheat to 325 degrees F.
- In a bowl, beat the butter and sugar with an electric mixer until soft and light. Beat in 3 of the eggs, one at a time, letting each one get incorporated before adding the next.
- Beat in the yogurt until well blended.
- Beat in the salt, mace (if using) and vanilla extract.
- In a separate small bowl, combine the remaining egg, with the milk.
- In third bowl, whisk together the flour and baking powder and sift once. (I just shake it through a strainer.)
- Beat in ⅓ of the flour. Then beat in half the milk mixture. Then ⅓ of the flour, half the milk and the remaining ⅓ flour – until everything is incorporated.
- Fill the pan about ⅚th full. Bake the pound cake at 325 degrees for about 1 hour or until it is well risen and colored, cracked on the surface, and a thin knife inserted in the thickest part of the cake comes out clean.
- Remove from the oven and place on a wire rack to cool in the pan.
- Once completely cool, gently run a sharp knife along the sides of the pan, carefully remove the cake from the pan and remove the paper.
- Wrap the cake tightly in plastic wrap and store at a cool room temperature in the refrigerator. If refrigerated, bring to room temperature before serving.
- It’s really important that your butter and eggs are at room temperature or the butter may separate while you are mixing giving the cake a rough, irregular texture, instead of a smooth, tender one.
If you like this lighter pound cake post, check out these links:
- One Bowl Olive Oil Pound Cake with Lemon & Lavender (Enlightened Cooking)
- Canola Oil Pound Cake with Browned Butter Glaze (Cooking Light/My Recipes)
- Lighter Than Normal Lemon Pound Cake (Kate in the Kitchen)
- Weight Watchers Vanilla Pound Cake
- My Skinny Low Fat Chocolate Cake Recipes
- My Skinny Low Fat Cinnamon Streusel Coffee Cake
- My Healthy Low Fat Banana Cake with Peanut Butter Frosting